Essay, Research Paper: The Book Of Revelation

Religion

Free Religion research papers were donated by our members/visitors and are presented free of charge for informational use only. The essay or term paper you are seeing on this page was not produced by our company and should not be considered a sample of our research/writing service. We are neither affiliated with the author of this essay nor responsible for its content. If you need high quality, fresh and competent research / writing done on the subject of Religion, use the professional writing service offered by our company.

The book of Revelation is the last profound book in the New Testament. It
conveys the significant purpose of Christianity by describing God's plan for the
world and his final judgement of the people by reinforcing the importance of
faith and the concept of Christianity as a whole. This book written by John in
95 or 96 AD, is the revelation of Jesus Christ illustrating the events that
occur before and during the second coming of Christ. By using complex symbolism
and apocalyptic metaphor the meaning of Revelation is defined. What is, what has
been, and what is to come is the central focus of the content. When correlating
the total concept of the book of Revelation the tremendous impact of the word of
God cannot be overlooked. Revelation was written in the last 3rd of the 1st
century clearly when the christians were being pressured by Rome to turn from
their faith to the Roman emperor. This book was intended for the seven churches
of Asia. Some think that the book was written around 64 AD, after the burning of
Rome. Revelation 11:1 references the temple suggesting that it is still standing
when history proves that the temple was destroyed by Titus in 70 AD. However,
this could simply be a prediction and have no relevance as to the date the book
was written. On the other hand, there is historical evidence that points to 95
or 96 AD as being the more probable date for the writing of this narrative.
Among these include statements from christian writers such as church father who
states that Revelation was written in the reign of the Roman emperor Domitian
(81-96). In addition this date better agrees with description of the early
churches and is accepted by them as well as by scholars as the better date. A
man named John wrote the book of Revelation on an island in the Argean Sea named
Patmos. This person is believed to be John the Apostle of Jesus Christ, author
of the fourth gospel. There has been some confusion over this, due to the fact
that John does not designate himself as an apostle and when mentioning them does
not include himself in that group. Rather he claims to be a prophet and his book
to be a prophecy. However, the early church as well as early theologians claim
the author as John the Apostle. In 480 AD five passages written by Iraneous
mentioned John specifically as the author, and in the middle of the 2nd century
Justin Marty quoted verbatim "attributing the authorship to John, an
apostle of Christ." (Tenney). In researching the fourth gospel and the book
of Revelation similarities do occur showing the book to be written by the same
person. A prime example being that the only mention of Jesus as logos in the
entire bible exists in these two books. If this book was not written by John the
Apostle, it was written by a John never before heard of or mentioned. Given
these facts and the past statements of christian writers it is highly likely
that the book of Revelation was in fact written by the apostle John, and is
agreed upon by most scholars today. The word revelation or apocaylpse has two
distinct meanings. In Latin "Revelatio" means unveiling and in Greek
"apokalypsis means the removing of a veil. The purpose of this book is the
revelation of Jesus Christ and the final judgement of the word of God. "The
coming of sin into the world, the establishment of the economy of redemption,
has necessitated the making known of truths not made known by general
revelation. Therefore, God has given the special revelation brought to us in the
Holy Scriptures. The scriptures reiterate the truths proclaimed in nature, in
history, and in man himself; and, in addition thereto, declare the salvation
which God has provided for mankind in Jesus Christ." (Unger 922). In
retrospect, revelation unveils God's future plan for the earth and is written to
be understood. Clearly the book of Revelation is the ultimate battle between
good and evil. It is the time when all sin will be judged, demons will be cast
away, and Christ will reign over the earth. This is the word of God showing us
his plan for the retribution of his son Jesus Christ. By sending these words to
John in a vision God is warning the people of the world to repent for their sins
and that the time is drawing near. "John to the seven churches which are in
Asia: Grace be unto you, and peace, from him which is, and which was, and which
is to come; and from the seven spirits which are before his throne;" (Rev.
1:4). The content of Revelation is very complex apocalyptic literature
consisting of many symbols some of which are explained and other are not. The
number seven occurs numerous times throughout this narrative. The number seven,
a perfect number, divisible by nothing meaning completeness. "The book is
broken down by four series of seven according to the theme of which is, which
was, and which is to come." (Ladd 14). Concluding with the fall of Babylon,
the final battle, and the new Jerusalem. By breaking down the content in this
way it is more easily explained, but keep in mind that there are a few brief
interruptions that do not apply to the derivative of seven. The first series of
the four are The Seven Letters (rev. 2:1-3:22). In these seven letter John sends
messages to the seven churches in Asia. Although research shows that this is
also meant towards other bodies outside of these seven churches. Each of these
letters begin with a characterization of Christ and praise to the churches for
the good deeds that they have accomplished. They then criticize the churches for
mistakes they have made ending with a promise of protection for those that
conquer. Moving on to what is to come he then writes of the second series of
seven. The Seven Seals (Rev. 6:1-17). The great tribulation lasting for a period
of seven years. A large scroll is described with seven seals to be broken, each
with a consequence, in order to reveal its contents. Not only does this scroll
contain the judgement of the wicked, but the redemption of the good as well.
These are the events leading up to the end of the world. The seals bring about a
horror of plagues to be suffered by the people such as war, famine, death, and
martyrdom for the righteous. Upon breaking the seals the sun will turn black,
the moon red like blood, stars will fall from the sky, and the people will hide
from the wrath of God. This revelation is the battle between good and evil, the
people against God, with satan's evil powers trying to destroy God through his
people. The antichrist, a false prophet, who deceives the people and requires
them to receive the mark of the beast or otherwise endure persecution. Even
though God has promised to protect his people he cannot protect them from
martyrdom. Outside of the series of seven he sends 144,000 martyrs, 12,000 of
each of the twelve tribes of Isreal to carry out his service. When the seventh
seal is opened a great silence falls over the earth marking the beginning of the
third series of seven. The Seven Trumpets (Rev. 8:2-14:20). These to are more
plagues to be ravished upon the people who have rejected Christ. A wrath so
severe that the destruction of the entire world is eminent. Throughout this
horror there is still time for the people to make a choice between Christ and
the Antichrist. The harshness of this wrath is not only to judge the people, but
to force them to fall to their knees and repent. This alone illustrates a
merciful God who is willing to forgive those who have betrayed him. Among these
plagues of the seven trumpets include the destruction of one third of the
vegetation of the earth, undescribable volcanic eruption, the loss of one third
of the life in the sea, complete darkness on the earth, locusts that will attack
the people to torture but not kill them, and finally death. Then again outside
of the series of seven God sends to witnesses to prophesize to the people. These
witness are murdered by the beast and left in the street to be looked upon by
the people who are rejoicing in this so called victory. The plagues of the
trumpets end with an earthquake that kills 7,000 people in the city of Babylon
marking that the end of the world has been announced. Finally the last series of
seven, The Seven Bowls. (Rev. 16:1-21). As the seven bowls are poured upon the
earth we see the divine judgement of Christ, the reaction of an unholy
civilization, and the final persecution of the church. Faith will be tested
because it will seem as if Satan has unlimited power and that all hope is gone.
God's wrath is fully unleashed and raging on those who bear the mark of the
beast. Horrible sores are cast upon the people, the sea turns to blood and every
living creature in it is destroyed, the entire water supply of the earth becomes
contaminated, the sun will scorch the people with fire and burn them, darkness
engulfs everything, and the river of Euphrates completely dries up. "This
last bowl is somewhat different from the others. In the Old Testament this river
is the boundary to the promised land and may be interpreted as the prelude to
the gathering of God's dispersed people in their own land." (Ladd 212).
With the pouring of the seventh bowl the voice of God says, "It is
done." Thunder booms, lightening strikes, and an earthquake erupts unlike
any that history has ever seen. The great city of Babylon splits into utter
destruction. Then, just as promised Christ returns to reign on earth for 1,000
years. The martyrs are resurrected to share in this time of great joy, Satan is
thrown into the abyss, and the earth restored is filled with peace. After this
millennial reign Satan will be released once again to deceive the people and
attempt to turn them against God in one final battle, the battle of Armageddon.
It is here that Satan is thrown into the lake of fire defeated forever. A new
Jerusalem is built, a new heaven and a new earth. The wicked are cast into the
lake of fire, the dead stand before God in final judgement, and the righteous
enter into eternal life. The book ends with John's warning against changing any
of this prophecy addressed to everyone who hears its word. The wrath, judgement,
and redemption of God is outlined in these pages. It is here that the entire
future of the world rests. "The Lord sent his angel to verify these words
in which he sent to John in a vision. The book of Revelation is the word of
Jesus Christ. "Do not seal up the words of the prophecy of this book,
because the time is near. Let him who does wrong continue to do wrong; let him
who is vile continue to be vile; let him who does right continue to do right;
and let him who is holy continue to be holy. Behold, I am coming soon! My reward
is with me, and I will give it to everyone according to what he has done. I am
the Alpha and Omega, the First and the Last, the Beginning and the End."
(Rev. 22:11- 12). When taking an intense look at this amazing book as a whole
the incredible impact that Revelation has on Christianity is recognized, for it
truly is the word of God. The unforgettable content and prophecy for the future
grasps the hearts of the believers and provides for the divine promise of
eternal life. "Genesis describes a paradise which was lost. Revelation
pictures a paradise restored." (Mounce 88). Bibliography Hendrikson,
William. More Than Conquerors. Baker Book House. Grand Rapids, Michigan. 1967.
Ladd, George Eldon. Revelation of John. William Eerdmans Publishing Company,
Grand Rapids, Michigan. 1972. Mounce, Robert H. The Book of Revelation. William
B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, Grand Rapids, Michigan. 1972. Tenny, Merril C.
Interpreting Revelation. Williams B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, Grand Rapids,
Michigan. 1957. Unger, Merrill F. Unger's Bible Dictionary. Moody Press,
Chicago, Illinois. 1957 An Insight Into Revelation The book of Revelation is the
last profound book in the New Testament. It conveys the significant purpose of
Christianity by describing God's plan for the world and his final judgement of
the people by reinforcing the importance of faith and the concept of
Christianity as a whole. This book written by John in 95 or 96 AD, is the
revelation of Jesus Christ illustrating the events that occur before and during
the second coming of Christ. By using complex symbolism and apocalyptic metaphor
the meaning of Revelation is defined. What is, what has been, and what is to
come is the central focus of the content. When correlating the total concept of
the book of Revelation the tremendous impact of the word of God cannot be
overlooked. Revelation was written in the last 3rd of the 1st century clearly
when the christians were being pressured by Rome to turn from their faith to the
Roman emperor. This book was intended for the seven churches of Asia. Some think
that the book was written around 64 AD, after the burning of Rome. Revelation
11:1 references the temple suggesting that it is still standing when history
proves that the temple was destroyed by Titus in 70 AD. However, this could
simply be a prediction and have no relevance as to the date the book was
written. On the other hand, there is historical evidence that points to 95 or 96
AD as being the more probable date for the writing of this narrative. Among
these include statements from christian writers such as church father who states
that Revelation was written in the reign of the Roman emperor Domitian (81-96).
In addition this date better agrees with description of the early churches and
is accepted by them as well as by scholars as the better date. A man named John
wrote the book of Revelation on an island in the Argean Sea named Patmos. This
person is believed to be John the Apostle of Jesus Christ, author of the fourth
gospel. There has been some confusion over this, due to the fact that John does
not designate himself as an apostle and when mentioning them does not include
himself in that group. Rather he claims to be a prophet and his book to be a
prophecy. However, the early church as well as early theologians claim the
author as John the Apostle. In 480 AD five passages written by Iraneous
mentioned John specifically as the author, and in the middle of the 2nd century
Justin Marty quoted verbatim "attributing the authorship to John, an
apostle of Christ." (Tenney). In researching the fourth gospel and the book
of Revelation similarities do occur showing the book to be written by the same
person. A prime example being that the only mention of Jesus as logos in the
entire bible exists in these two books. If this book was not written by John the
Apostle, it was written by a John never before heard of or mentioned. Given
these facts and the past statements of christian writers it is highly likely
that the book of Revelation was in fact written by the apostle John, and is
agreed upon by most scholars today. The word revelation or apocaylpse has two
distinct meanings. In Latin "Revelatio" means unveiling and in Greek
"apokalypsis means the removing of a veil. The purpose of this book is the
revelation of Jesus Christ and the final judgement of the word of God. "The
coming of sin into the world, the establishment of the economy of redemption,
has necessitated the making known of truths not made known by general
revelation. Therefore, God has given the special revelation brought to us in the
Holy Scriptures. The scriptures reiterate the truths proclaimed in nature, in
history, and in man himself; and, in addition thereto, declare the salvation
which God has provided for mankind in Jesus Christ." (Unger 922). In
retrospect, revelation unveils God's future plan for the earth and is written to
be understood. Clearly the book of Revelation is the ultimate battle between
good and evil. It is the time when all sin will be judged, demons will be cast
away, and Christ will reign over the earth. This is the word of God showing us
his plan for the retribution of his son Jesus Christ. By sending these words to
John in a vision God is warning the people of the world to repent for their sins
and that the time is drawing near. "John to the seven churches which are in
Asia: Grace be unto you, and peace, from him which is, and which was, and which
is to come; and from the seven spirits which are before his throne;" (Rev.
1:4). The content of Revelation is very complex apocalyptic literature
consisting of many symbols some of which are explained and other are not. The
number seven occurs numerous times throughout this narrative. The number seven,
a perfect number, divisible by nothing meaning completeness. "The book is
broken down by four series of seven according to the theme of which is, which
was, and which is to come." (Ladd 14). Concluding with the fall of Babylon,
the final battle, and the new Jerusalem. By breaking down the content in this
way it is more easily explained, but keep in mind that there are a few brief
interruptions that do not apply to the derivative of seven. The first series of
the four are The Seven Letters (rev. 2:1-3:22). In these seven letter John sends
messages to the seven churches in Asia. Although research shows that this is
also meant towards other bodies outside of these seven churches. Each of these
letters begin with a characterization of Christ and praise to the churches for
the good deeds that they have accomplished. They then criticize the churches for
mistakes they have made ending with a promise of protection for those that
conquer. Moving on to what is to come he then writes of the second series of
seven. The Seven Seals (Rev. 6:1-17). The great tribulation lasting for a period
of seven years. A large scroll is described with seven seals to be broken, each
with a consequence, in order to reveal its contents. Not only does this scroll
contain the judgement of the wicked, but the redemption of the good as well.
These are the events leading up to the end of the world. The seals bring about a
horror of plagues to be suffered by the people such as war, famine, death, and
martyrdom for the righteous. Upon breaking the seals the sun will turn black,
the moon red like blood, stars will fall from the sky, and the people will hide
from the wrath of God. This revelation is the battle between good and evil, the
people against God, with satan's evil powers trying to destroy God through his
people. The antichrist, a false prophet, who deceives the people and requires
them to receive the mark of the beast or otherwise endure persecution. Even
though God has promised to protect his people he cannot protect them from
martyrdom. Outside of the series of seven he sends 144,000 martyrs, 12,000 of
each of the twelve tribes of Isreal to carry out his service. When the seventh
seal is opened a great silence falls over the earth marking the beginning of the
third series of seven. The Seven Trumpets (Rev. 8:2-14:20). These to are more
plagues to be ravished upon the people who have rejected Christ. A wrath so
severe that the destruction of the entire world is eminent. Throughout this
horror there is still time for the people to make a choice between Christ and
the Antichrist. The harshness of this wrath is not only to judge the people, but
to force them to fall to their knees and repent. This alone illustrates a
merciful God who is willing to forgive those who have betrayed him. Among these
plagues of the seven trumpets include the destruction of one third of the
vegetation of the earth, undescribable volcanic eruption, the loss of one third
of the life in the sea, complete darkness on the earth, locusts that will attack
the people to torture but not kill them, and finally death. Then again outside
of the series of seven God sends to witnesses to prophesize to the people. These
witness are murdered by the beast and left in the street to be looked upon by
the people who are rejoicing in this so called victory. The plagues of the
trumpets end with an earthquake that kills 7,000 people in the city of Babylon
marking that the end of the world has been announced. Finally the last series of
seven, The Seven Bowls. (Rev. 16:1-21). As the seven bowls are poured upon the
earth we see the divine judgement of Christ, the reaction of an unholy
civilization, and the final persecution of the church. Faith will be tested
because it will seem as if Satan has unlimited power and that all hope is gone.
God's wrath is fully unleashed and raging on those who bear the mark of the
beast. Horrible sores are cast upon the people, the sea turns to blood and every
living creature in it is destroyed, the entire water supply of the earth becomes
contaminated, the sun will scorch the people with fire and burn them, darkness
engulfs everything, and the river of Euphrates completely dries up. "This
last bowl is somewhat different from the others. In the Old Testament this river
is the boundary to the promised land and may be interpreted as the prelude to
the gathering of God's dispersed people in their own land." (Ladd 212).
With the pouring of the seventh bowl the voice of God says, "It is
done." Thunder booms, lightening strikes, and an earthquake erupts unlike
any that history has ever seen. The great city of Babylon splits into utter
destruction. Then, just as promised Christ returns to reign on earth for 1,000
years. The martyrs are resurrected to share in this time of great joy, Satan is
thrown into the abyss, and the earth restored is filled with peace. After this
millennial reign Satan will be released once again to deceive the people and
attempt to turn them against God in one final battle, the battle of Armageddon.
It is here that Satan is thrown into the lake of fire defeated forever. A new
Jerusalem is built, a new heaven and a new earth. The wicked are cast into the
lake of fire, the dead stand before God in final judgement, and the righteous
enter into eternal life. The book ends with John's warning against changing any
of this prophecy addressed to everyone who hears its word. The wrath, judgement,
and redemption of God is outlined in these pages. It is here that the entire
future of the world rests. "The Lord sent his angel to verify these words
in which he sent to John in a vision. The book of Revelation is the word of
Jesus Christ. "Do not seal up the words of the prophecy of this book,
because the time is near. Let him who does wrong continue to do wrong; let him
who is vile continue to be vile; let him who does right continue to do right;
and let him who is holy continue to be holy. Behold, I am coming soon! My reward
is with me, and I will give it to everyone according to what he has done. I am
the Alpha and Omega, the First and the Last, the Beginning and the End."
(Rev. 22:11- 12). When taking an intense look at this amazing book as a whole
the incredible impact that Revelation has on Christianity is recognized, for it
truly is the word of God. The unforgettable content and prophecy for the future
grasps the hearts of the believers and provides for the divine promise of
eternal life. "Genesis describes a paradise which was lost. Revelation
pictures a paradise restored." (Mounce 88). Bibliography Hendrikson,
William. More Than Conquerors. Baker Book House. Grand Rapids, Michigan. 1967.
Ladd, George Eldon. Revelation of John. William Eerdmans Publishing Company,
Grand Rapids, Michigan. 1972. Mounce, Robert H. The Book of Revelation. William
B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, Grand Rapids, Michigan. 1972. Tenny, Merril C.
Interpreting Revelation. Williams B. Eerdmans Publishing Company, Grand Rapids,
Michigan. 1957. Unger, Merrill F. Unger's Bible Dictionary. Moody Press,
Chicago, Illinois. 1957 An Insight Into Revelation The book of Revelation is the
last profound book in the New Testament. It conveys the significant purpose of
Christianity by describing God's plan for the world and his final judgement of
the people by reinforcing the importance of faith and the concept of
Christianity as a whole. This book written by John in 95 or 96 AD, is the
revelation of Jesus Christ illustrating the events that occur before and during
the second coming of Christ. By using complex symbolism and apocalyptic metaphor
the meaning of Revelation is defined. What is, what has been, and what is to
come is the central focus of the content. When correlating the total concept of
the book of Revelation the tremendous impact of the word of God cannot be
overlooked. Revelation was written in the last 3rd of the 1st century clearly
when the christians were being pressured by Rome to turn from their faith to the
Roman emperor. This book was intended for the seven churches of Asia. Some think
that the book was written around 64 AD, after the burning of Rome. Revelation
11:1 references the temple suggesting that it is still standing when history
proves that the temple was destroyed by Titus in 70 AD. However, this could
simply be a prediction and have no relevance as to the date the book was
written. On the other hand, there is historical evidence that points to 95 or 96
AD as being the more probable date for the writing of this narrative. Among
these include statements from christian writers such as church father who states
that Revelation was written in the reign of the Roman emperor Domitian (81-96).
In addition this date better agrees with description of the early churches and
is accepted by them as well as by scholars as the better date. A man named John
wrote the book of Revelation on an island in the Argean Sea named Patmos. This
person is believed to be John the Apostle of Jesus Christ, author of the fourth
gospel. There has been some confusion over this, due to the fact that John does
not designate himself as an apostle and when mentioning them does not include
himself in that group. Rather he claims to be a prophet and his book to be a
prophecy. However, the early church as well as early theologians claim the
author as John the Apostle. In 480 AD five passages written by Iraneous
mentioned John specifically as the author, and in the middle of the 2nd century
Justin Marty quoted verbatim "attributing the authorship to John, an
apostle of Christ." (Tenney). In researching the fourth gospel and the book
of Revelation similarities do occur showing the book to be written by the same
person. A prime example being that the only mention of Jesus as logos in the
entire bible exists in these two books. If this book was not written by John the
Apostle, it was written by a John never before heard of or mentioned. Given
these facts and the past statements of christian writers it is highly likely
that the book of Revelation was in fact written by the apostle John, and is
agreed upon by most scholars today. The word revelation or apocaylpse has two
distinct meanings. In Latin "Revelatio" means unveiling and in Greek
"apokalypsis means the removing of a veil. The purpose of this book is the
revelation of Jesus Christ and the final judgement of the word of God. "The
coming of sin into the world, the establishment of the economy of redemption,
has necessitated the making known of truths not made known by general
revelation. Therefore, God has given the special revelation brought to us in the
Holy Scriptures. The scriptures reiterate the truths proclaimed in nature, in
history, and in man himself; and, in addition thereto, declare the salvation
which God has provided for mankind in Jesus Christ." (Unger 922). In
retrospect, revelation unveils God's future plan for the earth and is written to
be understood. Clearly the book of Revelation is the ultimate battle between
good and evil. It is the time when all sin will be judged, demons will be cast
away, and Christ will reign over the earth. This is the word of God showing us
his plan for the retribution of his son Jesus Christ. By sending these words to
John in a vision God is warning the people of the world to repent for their sins
and that the time is drawing near. "John to the seven churches which are in
Asia: Grace be unto you, and peace, from him which is, and which was, and which
is to come; and from the seven spirits which are before his throne;" (Rev.
1:4). The content of Revelation is very complex apocalyptic literature
consisting of many symbols some of which are explained and other are not. The
number seven occurs numerous times throughout this narrative. The number seven,
a perfect number, divisible by nothing meaning completeness. "The book is
broken down by four series of seven according to the theme of which is, which
was, and which is to come." (Ladd 14). Concluding with the fall of Babylon,
the final battle, and the new Jerusalem. By breaking down the content in this
way it is more easily explained, but keep in mind that there are a few brief
interruptions that do not apply to the derivative of seven. The first series of
the four are The Seven Letters (rev. 2:1-3:22). In these seven letter John sends
messages to the seven churches in Asia. Although research shows that this is
also meant towards other bodies outside of these seven churches. Each of these
letters begin with a characterization of Christ and praise to the churches for
the good deeds that they have accomplished.
1
0
Good or bad? How would you rate this essay?
Help other users to find the good and worthy free term papers and trash the bad ones.
Like this term paper? Vote & Promote so that others can find it

Get a Custom Paper on Religion:

Free papers will not meet the guidelines of your specific project. If you need a custom essay on Religion: , we can write you a high quality authentic essay. While free essays can be traced by Turnitin (plagiarism detection program), our custom written papers will pass any plagiarism test, guaranteed. Our writing service will save you time and grade.




Related essays:

0
0
Religion / Romero
Among those commemorated in new statues on the west front of Westminster Abbey "I am bound, as a pastor, by divine command to give my life for those whom I love, and that is all Salvadoreans, ev...
2667 views
0 comments
0
0
Religion / Romero
In the movie Romero, Archbishop Romero changes very much in his understanding of love and in his understanding of true conscience. At first Romero is just a priest who isn’t really concerned about th...
2549 views
0 comments
0
0
Religion / Ruth Gospel
The Book of Ruth sensitively portrays bonding and devotion between two women. [But also don't miss Book of Judith for a surprising overturning of male/female roles: Judith sneaks into the enemy camps...
3062 views
0 comments
0
0
St. Francis’s life began as any other man of his time. He was a wealthy individual who was preoccupied with material comforts. This preoccupation also led him to fear the poor, especially lepers. St...
2369 views
0 comments
0
0
This biography had a lot of information on St. Francis of Assisi. He was a very generous man who founded the Friars. Along the way he accomplished many good deeds. He gave all that he had to the poor...
3045 views
0 comments